What is Self Directed Trading Explained – Grasp the Basics

Find financial empowerment in knowledge. This blog explores the concept of self-directed trading, where individuals take the reins of their investments. Discover the ins and outs of this hands-on approach, navigating the complexities of DIY investing.

Self-directed trading, also known as do-it-yourself investing, is the practice of individuals building and managing their own investment portfolios. In self-directed trading, investors have the freedom to choose which investments to buy and sell, and when to make those decisions. Discount brokers and online trading platforms are commonly used by self-directed investors to execute their trades.

Key Takeaways:

  • Self-directed trading means individuals manage their own investment portfolios.
  • Advantages include lower fees, investment flexibility, and convenience.
  • Disadvantages include the need for increased research, discipline, and risk management.
  • Self-directed investors must educate themselves and develop effective trading strategies.
  • Successful self-directed trading requires a solid understanding of trading basics and fees.

What is Self Directed Trading

There are several advantages to self-directed trading. First, it offers lower fees compared to receiving advice from brokers. By utilising discount brokers and online platforms, investors can benefit from lower commissions and fees. Second, self-directed investors have the flexibility to invest in what they want. They can conduct their own research and make informed decisions based on their own investment strategies. Lastly, online trading platforms make self-directed trading convenient. Investors can trade from the comfort of their own homes, access real-time market information, and monitor their investments with ease.

However, there are also disadvantages to consider. Self-directed investors must be willing to dedicate time to conducting their own research, developing an investment plan, and keeping up with financial news. Additionally, there is a risk of trading too often or making costly trading mistakes if investors are not well-informed or disciplined. To be successful in self-directed trading, individuals must be prepared to educate themselves, develop effective trading strategies, and understand trading basics and associated fees.

Understanding Self-Directed Trading: Taking Control of Your Investment Journey

With regard to personal finance, the concept of self-directed trading stands as a beacon for individuals seeking autonomy in their investment decisions. This section aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of self-directed trading, delving into its intricacies, benefits, and the tools it offers to empower investors on their financial journey.

Defining Self-Directed Trading

Self-directed trading, often referred to as DIY (Do-It-Yourself) investing, is a strategy where individuals independently manage their investment portfolios. This approach enables investors to make crucial decisions related to buying, selling, and trading various financial instruments, including stocks, mutual funds, ETFs, and options. Unlike traditional investment models, self-directed trading places the decision-making power squarely in the hands of the investor.

Navigating the Self-Directed Landscape

To embark on a self-directed investment journey, individuals typically open self-directed brokerage accounts. These accounts provide a platform for investors to choose and manage their investments directly, all through online interfaces or phone services. This hands-on approach allows investors to tailor their portfolio according to their preferences and financial goals.

Consider an investor keen on incorporating a diverse range of assets into their portfolio, including specific stocks, bonds, and ETFs. Through a self-directed brokerage account, they have the freedom to execute trades and build a customised portfolio aligned with their investment strategy.

Tools for Self-Directed Investors

Self-directed investors often leverage discount brokers and online trading platforms to execute their trades efficiently. These platforms provide a plethora of tools and resources, empowering investors to conduct in-depth research, analyse market trends, and make informed decisions.

A self-directed investor utilising an online trading platform may access real-time market data, advanced charting tools, and educational resources. These tools enable them to stay informed about market movements and make timely decisions on their investments.

The Role of Discount Brokers

In the self-directed trading landscape, discount brokers play a pivotal role. These brokers offer trading services at lower commission rates compared to full-service brokers, making them a cost-effective choice for investors seeking greater control over their trades.

An investor opting for a discount broker to facilitate their self-directed trading can benefit from reduced transaction costs. This cost efficiency aligns with the DIY nature of self-directed trading, enabling investors to retain a larger portion of their returns.

Empowering Investors with Decision-Making Authority

Self-directed trading goes beyond mere transaction execution. It empowers investors with decision-making authority over their entire investment strategy. This includes determining when to buy or sell assets, rebalancing portfolios, and exploring diverse investment opportunities.

Imagine an investor wanting to capitalise on a specific market trend. In a self-directed approach, they can promptly adjust their portfolio, capitalising on emerging opportunities without relying on external advisors.

In conclusion, understanding self-directed trading is pivotal for investors aspiring to take control of their financial destiny. By navigating the self-directed landscape, investors can harness the freedom to shape their portfolios, make informed decisions, and actively participate in the dynamic world of finance.

Comparing Self-Directed and Automated Investing: Success in Investment

In the dynamic realm of investment, individuals are presented with the choice between self-directed trading and the convenience of automated investing. This section aims to dissect the nuances of these two approaches, providing a comprehensive understanding of their respective advantages and disadvantages.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Automated Investing

Automated investing, facilitated by systems like robo-advisors, offers a streamlined approach to managing portfolios. Understanding the pros and cons of this method is crucial for investors contemplating the adoption of automation in their investment strategy.


  1. Time Efficiency:
    Automated investing excels in saving time for investors. Once a chosen system is in place, day-to-day management is handled automatically. This is particularly beneficial for individuals with busy schedules who seek a hands-off investment experience. Example:
    Consider a professional with limited time for market research. Automated investing allows them to delegate the day-to-day management, ensuring their portfolio aligns with their goals without requiring constant attention.
  2. Professional Advice:
    Robo-advisors provide investors with access to professional advice without the need for a human financial advisor. This can be advantageous for those who value expert insights in their investment decisions. Example:
    An investor opting for a robo-advisor gains insights into market trends, risk management, and portfolio optimisation without the cost associated with hiring a human financial advisor.
  3. Potential Lower Risk:
    Automated investment portfolios often offer diversified, risk-managed strategies. This can be attractive for investors seeking a more hands-off approach and a potentially lower risk profile. Example:
    An individual with a conservative risk tolerance may opt for automated investing, benefiting from a pre-set risk level tailored to their preferences.


  1. Management Fees:
    One notable drawback of automated investing is the associated management fees. Robo-advisors typically charge a percentage of the assets under management (AUM), impacting the overall returns for investors. Example:
    Consider an investor with a robo-advisor charging a 0.25% management fee. On a £10,000 investment, this results in a £25 fee annually, reducing the net returns.
  2. Limited Personalisation:
    Automated portfolios may lack the level of personalisation achievable through self-directed investing. Investors using automated systems might find themselves with a more standardised portfolio. Example:
    An investor with specific preferences for individual stocks or unique investment strategies may find automated options restrictive, limiting their ability to tailor their portfolio according to their vision.
  3. Minimum Balance Requirements:
    Some robo-advisors impose minimum balance requirements for investors to access their services. This can be a barrier for those with smaller investment amounts. Example:
    An individual interested in automated investing may need to meet a minimum balance requirement of £5,000, potentially excluding investors with smaller budgets.

In conclusion, the choice between self-directed and automated investing hinges on individual preferences, risk tolerance, and the level of control an investor seeks. Navigating the advantages and disadvantages of each approach is crucial in crafting a tailored investment strategy aligned with personal financial goals.

Choosing Between Self-Directed and Automated Investing: A Decision-Making Guide

In the ever-evolving landscape of investment, individuals face a crucial decision – whether to embrace the hands-on approach of self-directed trading or opt for the convenience of automated investing. This section delves into the considerations and questions that can guide investors in making an informed choice tailored to their financial goals and preferences.

Key Considerations in Choosing Between Self-Directed and Automated Investing

  1. Comfort with Money and the Stock Market:
    A fundamental consideration is an individual’s comfort level with financial concepts and market dynamics. Investors confident in their understanding may find self-directed investing appealing, while those less versed might lean towards automated options. Example:
    An individual with a background in finance might feel confident in navigating market fluctuations and making informed decisions, making self-directed investing a suitable choice.
  2. Portfolio Customisation Needs:
    The degree of customisation an investor seeks in their portfolio is a pivotal factor. Self-directed trading offers unparalleled flexibility, allowing investors to curate portfolios with specific stocks, bonds, and alternative assets. On the other hand, automated investing may limit personalisation. Example:
    Consider an investor with a unique strategy, wanting to include specific stocks or alternative assets. Self-directed trading allows them the freedom to execute these strategies, creating a bespoke investment approach.
  3. Risk Tolerance and Investment Goals:
    Understanding one’s risk tolerance and long-term investment goals is crucial. Self-directed investors have the freedom to choose riskier assets, while automated investors might benefit from the risk management features inherent in some robo-advisor platforms. Example:
    An investor with a high-risk tolerance aiming for substantial returns may opt for self-directed trading to include riskier assets, while a conservative investor may prefer the risk-managed approach of automated investing.
  4. Enjoyment of Investment Activity:
    Considering whether investing is viewed as an enjoyable activity or more of a chore helps determine the preferred approach. Those who find researching securities and managing trades enjoyable may lean towards self-directed investing. Example:
    An individual passionate about staying informed on market trends, conducting research, and actively participating in investment decisions may find self-directed trading to be a fulfilling and engaging pursuit.

Making the Decision: Self-Directed or Automated?

After assessing these key considerations, investors can distil their preferences into actionable decisions.

  • Self-Directed Investing:
  • When to Choose: If comfortable with market intricacies, seeking portfolio customisation, and finding enjoyment in active investment participation.
  • Example: An investor passionate about exploring diverse assets and shaping a personalised portfolio might choose self-directed trading to align with their unique investment goals.
  • Automated Investing:
  • When to Choose: If seeking a more hands-off approach, valuing professional advice, and desiring risk-managed portfolios.
  • Example: An individual with a busy schedule and limited time for hands-on management may opt for automated investing, leveraging robo-advisors to handle day-to-day portfolio activities.

In conclusion, choosing between self-directed and automated investing is a highly individual decision. By carefully considering one’s comfort level, portfolio customisation needs, risk tolerance, and enjoyment of investment activities, investors can align their approach with their financial aspirations. Whether steering their own investment ship or relying on automation, the key is to make a choice that reflects personal preferences and long-term goals.

Advantages of Self Directed Trading

Self-directed trading offers several benefits, making it a popular choice for investors. By opting for self-directed trading, individuals can enjoy the following advantages:

  1. Lower fees: Self-directed investors can save on fees compared to those who rely on advice from brokers. They can purchase investments through discount brokers and online platforms, which often have lower commissions and fees.
  2. Investing freedom: Self-directed investors have the flexibility to invest in what they want. They can conduct their own research and make independent decisions, giving them full control over their investment portfolios.
  3. Convenient trading: Online trading platforms make self-directed trading easy and convenient. Investors can buy and sell stocks and other products from the comfort of their own homes. They can access research and trading information, as well as monitor their investments in real-time.

To fully capitalise on these benefits, self-directed investors should develop effective trading strategies and utilise the tools provided by their trading platforms. By doing so, they can maximise their potential returns and achieve their financial goals.

Advantages of Self Directed TradingDescription
Lower feesCompared to investors who rely on brokers, self-directed investors can pay lower fees by utilising discount brokers and online platforms.
Investing freedomSelf-directed investors have the freedom to invest in their preferred assets, conducting their own research and making independent decisions.
Convenient tradingWith online trading platforms, self-directed investors can enjoy the convenience of buying, selling, accessing research and trading information, and monitoring their investments from anywhere.

Disadvantages of Self Directed Trading

While self-directed trading has its advantages, it also comes with a set of disadvantages that investors should consider. Understanding these drawbacks is crucial for beginner traders and those exploring the option of self-directed trading for the first time. Below are some important points to keep in mind:

1. Comprehensive Responsibility

Self-directed investors have to shoulder all aspects of trading, including research, decision-making, and monitoring. This necessitates a significant time commitment and the ability to handle the emotional aspects of investing, particularly during volatile markets.

“Being a self-directed trader calls for taking full ownership of your investments. It requires dedicating time to research the market, analyse potential trades, and make informed decisions. Successful self-directed traders are disciplined, focused, and capable of managing the emotional ups and downs of the market.” – Alex Thompson, Financial Analyst

2. Frequent Trading Hazards

Self-directed investors often face the temptation of excessive trading, which can lead to higher fees and reduced investment returns. Emotional impulses and market fluctuations can prompt impulsive decision-making, jeopardising long-term investment strategies.

It is essential for self-directed traders to develop a disciplined investment strategy and not let emotions dictate their trading decisions. By sticking to a well-structured plan, traders can avoid the pitfalls of impulsive trading and improve their chances of long-term success.

3. Trading Platform Familiarity

In unfamiliarity lies the risk of costly trading mistakes. Self-directed investors who are not well-versed with the features and functionality of their chosen online trading platform may inadvertently make errors that can negatively impact their investment outcomes.

To mitigate this risk, it is crucial for self-directed traders to thoroughly familiarise themselves with their chosen trading platform. Learning about its features, tools, and potential pitfalls can help traders execute trades with confidence and avoid unintended errors.

“Self-directed trading requires a deep understanding of your chosen trading platform. Take the time to explore its functionality, practice using different features, and seek guidance from online resources or support teams provided by the trading platform.” – Susan Reynolds, Market Analyst

For beginner self-directed investors, it is advisable to seek tips and guidance from experienced traders. Starting with small investments and gradually expanding one’s knowledge and portfolio can help beginners gain valuable experience without taking on excessive risk.

Self Directed Trading vs Managed Accounts

When considering self-directed trading, it’s important to understand how it compares to managed accounts. The table below highlights some key differences between the two options:

Self Directed TradingManaged Accounts
ControlInvestor has full control over investment decisions and strategies.Investor delegates decision-making to a professional money manager.
FlexibilityInvestor can customise their investment portfolio and trading strategies.Investor relies on the expertise and guidance of the money manager.
Time CommitmentRequires time commitment to research, monitor, and make investment decisions.Less time commitment as investment decisions are taken care of by the money manager.
FeesLower fees compared to managed accounts.Higher fees due to professional expertise and management.

Choosing between self-directed trading and managed accounts depends on an individual’s goals, risk tolerance, and preferences. Self-directed trading offers more control and flexibility, while managed accounts provide professional expertise and convenience. It’s important for investors to carefully assess their own needs and consider what aligns best with their investment objectives.

Self Directed Trading vs Managed Accounts

Self-directed trading and managed accounts are two different approaches to investing, each with its own benefits and considerations. While self-directed trading allows individuals to have full control over their investment decisions and strategies, managed accounts involve delegating the decision-making process to a professional money manager. Let’s explore the key differences between these two options:

Self Directed Trading

In self-directed trading, individuals take charge of their own investment portfolios. They have the freedom to choose from a wide range of investment products and implement various trading strategies. Self-directed traders often utilise online trading platforms, offering direct access to the stock market and a suite of trading tools to enhance their decision-making process. This approach provides investors with maximum flexibility and customisation options.

Some advantages of self-directed trading include:

  • Full control over investment decisions
  • Ability to tailor investment strategies to personal preferences
  • Access to a wide range of investment products
  • Direct access to stock market trading
  • Opportunity to develop and refine investment skills

However, self-directed trading also requires investors to conduct their own research, keep up with market trends, and manage their portfolios diligently. It can be time-consuming and demands a certain level of knowledge and expertise.

Managed Accounts

Managed accounts, on the other hand, involve entrusting investment decisions to a professional money manager. These accounts are typically managed by experienced investment professionals or firms who make investment decisions on behalf of the account holder. Managed account providers aim to generate returns by considering the investor’s goals, risk tolerance, and investment objectives.

Some advantages of managed accounts include:

  • Access to professional expertise and guidance
  • Time-saving as investment decisions are delegated
  • Ability to benefit from the knowledge of seasoned professionals
  • Peace of mind knowing that investments are being actively managed

However, managed accounts come with management fees and limited flexibility compared to self-directed trading. Investors have less control over investment decisions and may have limited access to particular investment products or trading strategies.

Choosing Between Self Directed Trading and Managed Accounts

The choice between self-directed trading and managed accounts depends on various factors such as an individual’s investment goals, risk tolerance, time availability, and level of investment knowledge. Investors who enjoy being actively involved in the investment process and have the time and inclination to conduct thorough research may find self-directed trading more suitable. On the other hand, individuals who prefer a hands-off approach and value professional guidance may opt for managed accounts.

Self Directed TradingManaged Accounts
Full control over investment decisionsAccess to professional expertise and guidance
Flexibility to customise investment strategiesTime-saving as investment decisions are delegated
Access to a wide range of investment productsBenefit from the knowledge of seasoned professionals
Direct access to stock market tradingPeace of mind knowing investments are being managed

Ultimately, it’s crucial for investors to carefully consider their own preferences, goals, and risk tolerance when deciding between self-directed trading and managed accounts. Both options have their merits, and what works best for one individual may not be suitable for another. It’s essential to select an approach that aligns with your investment objectives and enables you to make informed decisions.


Self-directed trading provides individual investors with the opportunity to take control of their investment portfolios. By utilising online trading platforms, investors can enjoy the benefits of lower fees, investment flexibility, and the convenience of trading from the comfort of their own homes. However, self-directed trading also comes with its challenges.

Investors need to be prepared to invest time and effort into conducting their own research and staying informed about market trends. Developing effective trading strategies and maintaining discipline is crucial to avoid trading too often or making costly mistakes. Self-directed trading requires individuals to take on the responsibilities of managing their own investments, making it important to continuously educate themselves and adapt to changing market conditions.

Despite these challenges, self-directed trading can be a rewarding and profitable approach for those who are willing to put in the necessary effort. By continuously improving their knowledge and skills, self-directed investors can navigate the financial markets with confidence and make informed investment decisions. Whether one is a beginner or an experienced trader, the key to success lies in developing a solid foundation of trading strategies and staying up to date with market developments.


What is self-directed trading?

Self-directed trading is a form of investing where individual investors build and manage their own portfolios. They have the freedom to decide which investments to buy and sell and when to do so.

What are the benefits of self-directed trading?

Some benefits of self-directed trading include lower fees, the opportunity to invest in what you want, and the convenience of online trading. Self-directed investors have the freedom to choose their own investments and have full control over their portfolios.

What are some tips for self-directed trading beginners?

Beginners in self-directed trading should be willing to do their own research, develop an investment plan, keep up with financial news, and have a good understanding of trading basics and fees. It’s also important to seek guidance and consider starting with small investments to gain experience.

How does self-directed trading compare to managed accounts?

Self-directed trading gives individuals full control over their investment decisions and strategies, while managed accounts involve delegating decision-making to a professional. Self-directed trading offers more flexibility and the ability to customise an investment portfolio. Managed accounts provide the benefit of professional expertise and guidance.

What should individuals consider when deciding between self-directed trading and managed accounts?

Factors to consider include personal goals, risk tolerance, time commitment, investment knowledge, and preferences for control or professional guidance. It’s important to weigh the advantages and disadvantages of each approach to determine the best fit for individual needs.

PIP Penguin